Lake Worth car dealer accused of rolling back odometers in sweeping fraud scheme

www.cbs12.com, November 10, 2026, Grace Bellinghausen

LAKE WORTH BEACH, Fla. (CBS12) — A Lake Worth Beach car dealer is accused of shaving more than 100,000 miles off used cars before selling them to unsuspecting buyers.

Anthony Rodriguez, 33, owner of Brother's Best Deal Auto Sales, is accused of running an elaborate odometer fraud scheme involving altered mileage, falsified paperwork and fraudulent license plates, according to a 36-page warrant affidavit from the Florida Highway Patrol.

Investigators reviewed 139 vehicles sold by the dealership in 2024 and 2025 and discovered more than half had mileage discrepancies, according to FHP.

The investigation began after a woman purchased a 2016 Kia Sedona that had more than 182,000 miles when the dealership acquired it. By the time she bought it, the odometer showed just 68,000 miles — roughly 114,000 miles less.

And investigators say it wasn't an isolated incident.

A Kia Forte with 251,000 miles was allegedly sold showing just 125,000 miles, while a Nissan Altima with more than 235,000 miles was sold showing approximately 125,000.

The Altima's buyer told investigators she spent more than $5,000 on repairs and never would have purchased the car had she known its actual mileage.

According to FHP, the dealership allegedly purchased high-mileage vehicles at auctions before having their odometers rolled back by a man employees called the "electrician" or "key guy."

One former employee estimated that roughly 13 out of every 20 cars had fraudulent mileage.

Investigators identified the alleged "key guy," who denied manipulating odometers and claimed he only made car keys for the dealership.

During questioning, Rodriguez allegedly admitted altering paperwork after customers signed it without notifying them.

When asked why he manipulated odometers, Rodriguez reportedly told investigators it was for financial reasons to keep the business afloat, acknowledging that higher-mileage vehicles sold for less money. However, he denied personally rolling back the odometers.

Investigators also uncovered allegedly fraudulent temporary license plates and seized eight vehicles with suspicious mileage during searches of two dealerships.

Rodriguez was arrested Friday and faces an organized fraud charge involving property valued at $50,000 or more and multiple felony counts related to vehicles with tampered odometers, according to FHP.

News article: Lake Worth car dealer accused of rolling back odometers in sweeping fraud scheme